Is alienation a step towards becoming democratic citizens?
In order to strengthen democratic formation, we must first recognize that we all carry the antithesis of democracy within ourselves. In essence, this is the core idea in Associate Professor Asger Sørensen’s higher doctoral dissertation, titled Educating through alienation to democracy, which he will defend at the Danish School of Education (DPU) on 10 November. At a time when democracy is under pressure on multiple fronts, Asger Sørensen aims to demonstrate how alienation is a fruitful concept for understanding how we might be formed into democratic citizens.
The higher doctoral dissertation Educating through alienation to democracy represents the culmination of Asger Sørensen’s lifelong research project and his personal commitment to democracy and citizenship. In a social-philosophical analysis spanning over 600 pages, he examines concepts such as democracy, alienation, modernity, and formation in what is not just an academic thesis, but equally a defence of democracy.
Meanwhile, Asger Sørensen – an associate professor of philosophy of education at the Danish School of Education (DPU), Aarhus University – believes that a higher doctoral dissertation on this topic should not be necessary.
"Most people can get behind our democratic ideals. While there are, of course, many practical details to work out regarding their implementation, most people can agree on the fundamental principles: collective self-determination, enlightenment, freedom, education, and solidarity", he says.
Of course, it is not quite that simple. Particularly from the 2010s onwards, cracks have begun to appear in Western democracy, alongside growing scepticism regarding its core principles. Asger Sørensen highlights several notable examples: the Trump administration in the United States, the 2021 attack on the US Capitol, the Orbán regime in Hungary, and various far-right movements across Europe.
This scepticism and these cracks provide the basis for his dissertation.
As he explains, “Democracy seemingly generates resistance against itself. My thesis is that we can understand, and perhaps even overcome, this resistance by introducing the concept of alienation. On the one hand, there appears to be widespread alienation in response to phenomena such as modernity, education, and democracy – ideals that should in fact unite us. On the other hand, this very alienation may be a necessary step towards realizing those same ideals”.
Alienation is not just about loss, but also about giving
Of course, it is crucial to define what is meant by "alienation", and Asger Sørensen devotes a significant portion of his dissertation to discussing the concept. "The familiar meaning of alienation is that something becomes alien to you. You become alienated from yourself, from existence, or from the society in which you live, not feeling at home in any of these contexts. The classic existentialist analysis is concerned with the absurdity of life, but there are also familiar Marxist analyses of capitalist society, where private property and the economy as a whole are said to alienate individuals from themselves, from one another, and ultimately from the society that they are part of".
As such, alienation involves losing part of oneself. However, Asger Sørensen suggests viewing it from a different angle: what is lost may also be something that is given – something that one might even *want* to give.
"To offer a concrete example, if you want to establish and participate in a binding community, you must also give something of yourself. You have to surrender some of your personal sovereignty, relinquish certain resources, or compromise on some of your values. This is a form of voluntary alienation that one chooses to enter into", says Asger Sørensen, citing the French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau as an example. In his book The Social Contract (1762), Rousseau describes how each of us must surrender sovereignty in order to form a political society, and thus the basic prerequisite for democracy.
We all carry this division within us
Asger Sørensen’s starting point is the current tension between the ideal of a democratic society and the forces working against it. Although the German philosopher G.W.F. Hegel was certainly no democrat, his ideas about modernity, *Bildung* (formation/education), and alienation provide a basis for understanding the divisions that characterize our world today. Consequently, Hegel – alongside philosophers such as Karl Marx, Jürgen Habermas, and Herbert Marcuse – occupies a central place in Asger Sørensen’s dissertation.
“As early as 200 years ago, Hegel analysed ideals such as enlightenment, *Bildung*, self-realization, solidarity, and, not least, the republican constitutional state. These ideals have only grown stronger since then and have largely been realized. We have seen the establishment of the UN, the European Court of Human Rights, and the International Criminal Court; we have representative democracies with universal and equal suffrage; and there is no doubt that modernity has brought about significant progress”, says Asger Sørensen.
However, during this same period, we have also witnessed two world wars, the Holocaust, and Hiroshima. In the 21st century alone, there has been a rise in polarization and hatred, accompanied by widespread scepticism towards democratic ideals.
For Asger Sørensen, the awareness that – both as a society and as individuals – we carry both of these aspects within us is an important point, not just politically, but certainly also from a pedagogical perspective. The dissertation deals with ‘democracy’ and ‘alienation’; however, above all, it concerns ‘educating’ – a term encompassing both the broader concept of *Bildung* and formal education. "An important part of democratic formation is understanding that democracy and modernity always seem to be accompanied by division and alienation – and that the division we are witnessing on a global stage is also a division we all carry within ourselves: on one hand, holding and firmly believing in strong democratic ideals, while on the other hand being self-sufficient individuals who feel entitled to that status. Recognizing this is a significant step towards understanding why a regulated society that is characterized by collective self-determination and representative democracy is preferable to a utopian state of anarchy with no overarching governance", says Asger Sørensen, adding:
"Learning that, while abuse of power and greed exist, so too do legitimate authority, generosity, and solidarity may be the kind of formation and education that enables us to continue the democratic project".
Asger Sørensen is an optimist, in that he believes in the democratic project. His higher doctoral dissertation sets out the political-philosophical argument for this belief. He will defend his dissertation on Tuesday, 10 November, at the Danish School of Education (DPU), Aarhus University, in Copenhagen.
Find further details about the programme
The dissertation is available via Open Access. You can also purchase the printed edition of the dissertation at a 35% discount until 31 December 2026:
Discount code: DGBCONFD4
Click here to access the Open Access version or to purchase the dissertation
The dual meaning of alienation
In his dissertation, Asger Sørensen demonstrates that the concept of alienation carries a dual meaning. Rather than being an exclusively negative term, it can also have positive connotations. He concedes that this may sound strange when using the Danish word *fremmedgørelse* or the German *Entfremdung*. However, this duality becomes clear when using the English word *alienation*, or in French (*aliénation*) or Spanish (*alienación*). In these three languages, *alienation* also refers to the regulated, formal, and legal transfer of something of one’s own to someone else – a transfer of value or sovereignty.